Score: 65% Feature creep: The controller.

Almost ultimate 8BitDo's ultimate Ulimate controller isn't quite as ultimate as it could be, but it's pretty close.

Cheap thrills A cheap-yet-cheerful starting point to an otherwise expensive hobby.

Axial size You've heard of direct drive, but how about direct axial drive?

Quality clicks Feature-rich and featuring top-notch quality and ergonomics, it's almost the perfect controller—but not quite.

Sticking point A controller with TMR sticks, Hall effect triggers, and far too many cut corners.

Neat-o Looks a little square but is actually one of the coolest dudes you know.

Wheely good The wheel upgrade I've been waiting for.

Cheap sticks The gorgeous and premium-feeling 8BitDo Ultimate 2C could rule the budget controller roost.

Spin cycle A great "pro" gamepad with hall effect sticks and a novel modular design.