Commenting rules and guidelines

2015-04-28 00016

We like providing a commenting system so you can express yourself and share information with other readers, and for the most part, you're free to speak your mind under our articles. We do want our community to be a friendly and welcoming place for everyone, though, so there are a few rules. We have a small team of moderators working alongside us, and although we can’t be everywhere at once, we're committed to making the comments a pleasant place for as many readers are possible. With that in mind, these are the key rules:

  • Don't post racist, sexist, homophobic, or otherwise bigoted comments.
  • Don't post threats or encourage self-harm.
  • Don't post or link to anything pornographic, disgusting (in-game gore is a grey area, but use common sense), or illegal (including illegal file sharing).
  • Don't spam: no excessive posting, repeated self-promotion, or paid referral links.

People who break these rules will have their comments deleted, be forced to play Counter-Strike with a controller, and will probably be permanently banned.

We also have some general guidelines. We will ban people if they break these repeatedly:

  • Don't be intentionally rude. We've met a lot of PC Gamer readers, and they're all lovely in real life. It's easy to sound like more of a dick than you are in a comments thread—take it easy, be nice, and you'll find that everyone's generally pretty cool.
  • "Meh" is not a valid sentiment. If you don't care, don't reply. The same goes for "first," "meanwhile in Syria," and other non-contributory meme-style statements which will likely be deleted by the moderators and editors without warning.
  • If you disagree with someone, say why. If you agree with someone, say why. If you like or dislike something, say why. If you can't be bothered to say why, that's fine, just move on.
  • We're happy to read polite criticism, but baseless accusations of bribery, corruption, or that we're part of the illuminati ruling from an undersea lair won't be regarded kindly. If you think we've acted improperly, your complaint can be taken up with Future management or the relevant authorities. PC Gamer has been producing independent and critical reviews for over twenty years. Nothing is going to change that. Our reviews policy can be found here.

All of the rules can be neatly encapsulated in our golden rule: don't be a dick. 

Please note that we may also disable comments altogether on certain articles. A small number of topics have been proven to inspire a large volume of heated, and sometimes hateful discussion. Therefore we will opt to shut threads that have descended into widespread abuse. This may also be done preemptively, for topics which have consistently drawn unconstructive discussions.

We don't want to shut down criticism—be it of games, companies, or us—but in order to keep our comments a welcoming, friendly place, we have to draw lines between criticism and shouting, skepticism and baseless accusations, and disagreement and hate. Be funny, be critical, be supportive, or be angry—just don't be a jerk about it. 

If these rules and guidelines are unacceptable to you, that's also fine, and you are of course free to express yourself elsewhere on the internet. Publishing comments on the site is an editorial decision, and we ultimately have final say over what appears. To use a slightly labored analogy: Imagine the comments section as a party. Everyone is invited, and we want you all to have a good time. But if you walk in, jump on the table, start screaming, and then throw up on the carpet don't be surprised if you're asked to leave.

If you're interested in volunteering as a community moderator, feel free to shoot an e-mail to, including your Disqus username.