The cake was a lie, but Silksong 'is real, progressing and will release' say devs, after flurry of conspiracy theories revealed to be a 'nothingburger'

Hollow Knight: Silksong — Hornet, the heroine of the Hollow Knight sequel, leaping into action.
(Image credit: Team Cherry)

Alright, Silksong gang, pack up the cork boards and sorrowfully spool away your red string—turns out we were being had. Or maybe just drunk on pattern recognition. Most definitely the latter.

In case you've been out of the loop (honestly, you're better off), the Silksong community had a conniption last week after a developer William Pellen's alt account, typically used for shitposting, changed its handle and profile picture to some chocolate, then cryptically tweeted out the words "something big is coming. keep your eyes closed tomorrow".

Like a horde of hungry zombies that'd just been thrown an arm, the much-starved fanbase crowded around and began to draft conspiracy theories. Some of which I was even buying into, like how the account's new handle, "little bomey", was a reference to Napoleon Bonaparte—it's a whole thing. All signs seemed to point to April 2, 2024—turns out, those signs were wrong.

Hollow Knight speed and challenge runner fireb0rn posted to X that Matthew Griffin—otherwise known as Leth, who handles marketing and publishing for Team Cherry, had "reached out to me to confirm there was no Silksong ARG, and that the changes to William's account and the tweet were a nothingburger. Apologies to have misled everyone. The cake was a lie."

This was then seemingly confirmed by Griffin, who, in a response to a quote tweet, reassures gamers that: "Yes the game is real, progressing and will release. <3".

So, how's the fanbase doing? Uh—not super great, as one post discussing the letdown shows. "Radio silence for years when asked to give any kind of update, response within two days for this though," writes one despondent player on the r/Silksong subreddit. "I am honestly sick of these kinds of bait," writes another, "they are large (coming from William after all) so of course all spring into action and hope, just to be crushed."

The main Hollow Knight subreddit seems similarly disappointed, but not surprised. "Leth should take a break from all this typing before he gets carpal tunnel," a detractor jokes, referencing the marketer's long silences. That is a little harsh—but in fairness, Team Cherry has been habitually and perpetually quiet about the project other than some promises that it's totally happening, with news droughts stretching into the hundreds of days.

That might be because whenever Team Cherry says anything at this point, its fan community descends upon those words like a swarm of starved locusts—which, I get, even if they can be a touch melodramatic. At the very least, it's not solid optics to put a trailer in a 2022 showcase of games ready to come out in the same year, before spending three more years developing it with nothing but an occasional squeak. Let's hope there's some proper news soon, for the sanity of everyone—and not least that poor "Daily Silksong News" guy, whose long vigil may very well continue.

Best laptop gamesBest Steam Deck gamesBest browser gamesBest indie gamesBest co-op games

Best laptop games: Low-spec life
Best Steam Deck games: Handheld must-haves
Best browser games: No install needed
Best indie games: Independent excellence
Best co-op games: Better together

Harvey Randall
Staff Writer

Harvey's history with games started when he first begged his parents for a World of Warcraft subscription aged 12, though he's since been cursed with Final Fantasy 14-brain and a huge crush on G'raha Tia. He made his start as a freelancer, writing for websites like Techradar, The Escapist, Dicebreaker, The Gamer, Into the Spine—and of course, PC Gamer. He'll sink his teeth into anything that looks interesting, though he has a soft spot for RPGs, soulslikes, roguelikes, deckbuilders, MMOs, and weird indie titles. He also plays a shelf load of TTRPGs in his offline time. Don't ask him what his favourite system is, he has too many.

Read more
An image of Hornet from Silksong engulfed with rage.
The Silksong hive is buzzing over a dev tweet that sees a chocolate cake, Napoleon Bonaparte, and Imagine Dragons all pointing with red string to the April Switch 2 Nintendo Direct
An image of Hornet from Hollow Knight: Silksong standing amidst a verdant landscape.
1,465 consecutive days of (mostly) no Silksong news: I spoke to the Sisyphean internet hero that's kept folks informed, every 24 hours, for 4 whole years
Hollow Knight: Silksong — Hornet, the heroine of the Hollow Knight sequel, leaping into action.
Hollow Knight: Silksong—Everything we know
The G-Man looking at the camera.
G-Man's voice actor rings in the new year by dropping a cryptic tweet grenade promising 'unexpected surprises' into the starving Half-Life 3 fanbase
Path of Exile 2 early access class key art
Path of Exile fans are having a very normal one after an expansion was delayed thanks to Path of Exile 2: 'I need to make peace with myself and let go of this burden'
Stardew Valley farmer interacting with her Goat, which has a little heart over its head from improving affection levels.
I want Eric Barone to make his new game, but I get why he's still fixing Stardew bugs
Latest in Action
A peaceful hideout with a pond in Japan
The thing I'm most excited about in Assassin's Creed Shadows is my hideout: 'a little over one acre of fully customizable land' to build on, decorate, and fill with pettable baby deer
Monster Hunter Wilds - a hunter faces off against Doshaguma in a field
Why did Monster Hunter Wilds dedicate so much effort to its environments, only to completely drop the actual 'hunting' from Monster Hunter?
Assassin&#039;s Creed Shadows key art.
Ubisoft reveals Assassin's Creed Shadows preload and unlock times
Monster Hunter Wilds events - Ajarakan roaring
All Monster Hunter Wilds event quests and rewards
A hunter grins and throws two peace/victory signs while wearing a Mimiphyta helm in Monster Hunter Wilds.
The first Monster Hunter Wilds event quests let you wear an adorable forest creature as a helmet, which means my headgear is locked in for the next few months
Olivia scowls in Monster Hunter Wilds.
Monster Hunter Wilds feels easy at launch—but after a decade of fighting post-release elder dragons and Master Rank monsters, I'm not worried about the light warmup
Latest in News
A peaceful hideout with a pond in Japan
The thing I'm most excited about in Assassin's Creed Shadows is my hideout: 'a little over one acre of fully customizable land' to build on, decorate, and fill with pettable baby deer
Civilization 7 victory guide
Firaxis says it's 'entering our Sukritact Age' as it hires popular modder to work on Civilization 7
Three heroes stand against a tide of skeletons
The Hand of Fate devs are back with a bullet heaven called Hordes of Fate
Cities: Skylines 2 screenshot - street level at night
Cities: Skylines 2's asset editor remains a distant dream: Colossal Order is still working on it but says it's 'proven more technically challenging than initially anticipated'
Assassin&#039;s Creed Shadows key art.
Ubisoft reveals Assassin's Creed Shadows preload and unlock times
talk to the joneses fortnite
Epic's war against the Fortnite fraudsters sees it simultaneously name and shame alleged ne'er-do-wells as its high-powered lawyers sue them