Warhammer: Vermintide 2 review

Matchmaking woes and annoyingly obtuse stats don't rob the fun out of Vermintide 2's gleefully gory combat.

Our Verdict

Vermintide 2's combat and level design are so feverishly fun that I'll put up with its bad matchmaking and RPG progression if it means chopping more ratmen in half.

PC Gamer's got your back Our experienced team dedicates many hours to every review, to really get to the heart of what matters most to you. Find out more about how we evaluate games and hardware.


What is it? Left 4 Dead meets apocalyptic fantasy Warhammer but with loot.
Reviewed On: Windows 10, i5 3570k, 16GB Ram, GTX 970
Price: $30
Release Date: Out now
Publisher: Fatshark
Developer: Fatshark
Multiplayer: Four-player co-op.
Link: Official Website 

Warhammer: Vermintide 2's 'AI director' is sadistic. With a lumbering Chaos Warrior already attacking us, the AI summons an armored Stormvermin ambush from behind. Pinched on both sides, they quickly knock out Bardin the dwarf, Kruber the mercenary, and Sienna the fire mage, leaving only me, the nimble elf Kerillian, to save us. Shit's dire, but we've survived worse. 

Then, out of nowhere, the AI summons a Chaos Sorcerer. Usually these special enemies like to hang out at a distance and summon tornados that scatter us to the wind—an attack I can easily dodge, but this Chaos Sorcerer wants to make it personal. He teleports to me and begins sucking the soul out of my body, rendering me completely helpless. A party member could save me, but that's pretty hard to do when they're already incapacitated. It's a cruel end to our adventure made even more sinister when, as I'm slowly being dragged to the sorcerer, the Chaos Warrior storms up and finishes me off with a coup de grâce even though I was already as good as dead. I half expect the AI to start teabagging me.

Fatshark's sequel is challenging and thrilling, but it can also be frustrating as hell when the multiplayer fails.

Vermintide 2 can be maddeningly difficult. One or two of my teammates will be incapacitated, surrounded by vermin, and it'll feel like it's game over. Then my hammer smashes in the skull of the last Rotblood and my tunnel vision widens. It's over. We survived. Moments like this evoke the vicious action of Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings—especially when you're an elf, a dwarf, and a human fighting your way through a mine filled with trolls. 

As good as Vermintide 2 is at creating epic scenes of tension (even if it sometimes goes too far), it's diminished by a frustrating multiplayer setup that can steal away what valuable agency you have over that experience. Fatshark's sequel is challenging and thrilling, but it can also be frustrating as hell when the multiplayer fails.

Not my kind of grind 

Like the first game, Vermintide 2 is a Left 4 Dead-style, four-player co-op first-person action game in which your party wades through treacherous levels fighting off hordes of Skaven, who have now allied with the vicious Chaos raiders. Set during Warhammer's End Times, Vermintide 2's apocalyptic fantasy setting is disturbing and marvellous. Its 13 levels tour ruined cities and treacherous bogs that are each as gorgeous and moody as the last. 

Performance analysis

We're still working on the full article, but our performance analysis video shows how Vermintide 2 runs on a variety of graphics cards and CPUs. The game is playable at 30-60 fps, thanks to the predominantly melee combat that favors swinging a sword over precise aim, so anything more than 60 fps is merely a bonus. Having a decent CPU can help keep framerates from bogging down when you're attacked by a horde of Skaven or Rotblood raiders, and dropping settings to medium or low will help on less potent rigs.

With each mission lasting about 30 minutes, you'll end up repeating them. That might sound boring, but each level is expansive enough that revisiting them never feels repetitive thanks, in part, to the AI director mixing up enemy spawn locations. It's a system that mostly works, though some areas of each mission do bleed together because fighting a group of Skaven doesn't feel all that different from fighting a group of Rotblood raiders. 

This uncertainty of what enemies spawn, and where, has surprising benefits. In one sequence, my party escorted a minecart through a pitch black stretch of an abandoned mine. The first time I played this mission we had a terrifying fight against a troll that came charging at us from the dark. Another time we were ambushed by a horde of naked clanrats. During my third playthrough, nothing attacked us at all. The silence put me on edge for minutes.

I particularly love the mission Righteous Stand, which starts you in a massacred mountain city before ending with a desperate fight inside an expansive, ruined temple. This finale sees a near endless horde of enemies swarming the party with no salvation in sight until the dormant magic of the cathedral miraculously saves the day.

To say that Vermintide 2 is gory is an understatement.

It's the thrill of severing Skaven limbs or surviving an all-out rush by the Rotblood horde that keeps me invested.

Unlike Left 4 Dead, however, Vermintide 2 is wearing layers of RPG underwear. It's a lot to take in at first, but I've come to love the nuances each character career (a kind of subclass) offers because each one plays a subtle but crucial role in a party. The five characters have their own special ability, passive bonuses, unlockable skill trees, and weapons. Once you level a character up a bit, you'll also unlock new careers that offer vastly different play styles in addition to each having their own separate skill tree.

Bardin the dwarf's Ironbreaker career is probably my favorite because it transforms him into the closest thing Vermintide has to a tank. When my special meter fills up, I can unleash an ear-splitting roar that draws the ire of every nearby enemy. Fortunately, this ability also grants me unlimited stamina for the next few seconds that I can use to block attacks. With all eyes (and swords) on me, my team can quickly carve through the baddies.

You'd think a loot system would be reason enough to keep playing, but it's the thrill of severing Skaven limbs or surviving an all-out rush by the Rotblood horde that keeps me invested. Despite only using the left and right mouse buttons to attack and block, there's a satisfying depth to combat. Each of the 50-ish weapons has their own timing, attack arcs, and reach but the fighting never feels clumsy or technical. A few swings with a new weapon was all I needed to understand how to best use it in combat.

Bardin's drakegun is a flamethrower that can ignite dozens of enemies when fully charged, while Kerillian's Asrai hunting bow is basically an assault rifle that shoots arrows. Each of the melee weapons is similarly varied, and just when I think I prefer large, slow weapons, like Kruber's halberd and its ability to decapitate multiple enemies in a single swipe, I try out Kerillian's dual daggers and fall in love with how rapidly she can dice wimpy ratmen. 

Video: Grimoires are hidden across each map, and can be picked up to increase your loot odds at the cost of a teamwide HP penalty.

Dodges, parries, and charged attacks were a lot more difficult to master, however. Vermintide 2 feels especially difficult in the first few hours. Despite an entertaining narrative tutorial, it's terrible at explaining how to use these different moves properly. Now that I've mastered the basics, though, I love how challenging Vermintide 2 can be at higher difficulties, where a single enemy attack can nearly kill me. That level of mortality turns even a small fight into a tense dance of slashing and dodging. And if I really want to amp the challenge up, each mission has hidden tomes and grimoires which take up valuable inventory slots and lower the party's overall health in exchange for better loot. I do sometimes resent how mandatory they feel when the party is already struggling to survive, however.

A good team is just as necessary as good reflexes, and Vermintide 2 shines when you're playing with a group of friends. Special monsters like the Skaven Packmaster will slip behind my party during a fight and will try and yank one of us away, requiring the group to move quickly and save our friend. That's not nearly as bad as when a green circle appears at the party's feet, heralding a deadly tornado from a Chaos Sorcerer. These moments are so common, but always surprising, that each session feels like a brutal gauntlet. There are times when the whole party dies and the sense of shared frustration is palpable, but those moments when we do survive are so satisfying.

Winner loot all 

It's not that losing in Vermintide 2 can't be fun, but that there's so many variables that can create failure beyond my control.

While I like Vermintide 2's loot, I hate how I receive and manage it. The inventory screen is poorly organized and rarely displays information that is actually useful. Characters can also share and equip the same trinkets and charms, but there's no ‘equip all’ button. I have to painstakingly switch from character to character to update their gear and free up their currently equipped items for salvaging. It's a nightmare.

Astonishingly, Vermintide 2 lacks a menu that shows even the most basic stats like health or stamina. I'm all for RPG systems that deviate from the norm (Dark Souls 3, I'm looking at you), but it's frustrating how obtuse Vermintide 2 is with its underlying mathematics and stats because it makes meaningful experimentation impossible. Why include weapons that up my chance of scoring a critical hit if I can't determine what my base chance is? Even the meaning of Hero Power, the total measurement of my character's prowess, is hidden behind an easily missed tooltip.

The moments when Rotblood raiders and ratmen Skaven have my party surrounded are thrilling, but if the party dies, I'm often left feeling my time is wasted. It's not that losing in Vermintide 2 can't be fun, but that there are so many variables that can create failure beyond my control. If the party leader (and host of the match) disconnects, all the progress I made on that mission is erased and I have to start over. There's also no way to kick troublesome party members and no indicator of who is speaking using the in-game voice chat. Even my latency is pointlessly hidden. I can do everything right in a mission and still lose due to things I can't control. When coupled with the fact that loot is only rewarded when you successfully beat a mission or gain a level, Vermintide 2 can feel stingy for all the wrong reasons. It's not fun to be deprived of loot necessary to tackling harder difficulties because the host quit.

It's frustrating that a sequel would still struggle to nail such simple multiplayer basics, and the obscured RPG progression doesn't entice me the way it does in similar games. But Vermintide 2 succeeds on the merits of its stellar combat and level design. After nearly 40 hours, that Rotblood warhorn signalling a zerg-like rush of raiders, or the sound of a Gutter Runner assassin chattering in the darkness, still turns my blood to ice.

The Verdict
Warhammer: Vermintide 2

Vermintide 2's combat and level design are so feverishly fun that I'll put up with its bad matchmaking and RPG progression if it means chopping more ratmen in half.

Steven Messner

With over 7 years of experience with in-depth feature reporting, Steven's mission is to chronicle the fascinating ways that games intersect our lives. Whether it's colossal in-game wars in an MMO, or long-haul truckers who turn to games to protect them from the loneliness of the open road, Steven tries to unearth PC gaming's greatest untold stories. His love of PC gaming started extremely early. Without money to spend, he spent an entire day watching the progress bar on a 25mb download of the Heroes of Might and Magic 2 demo that he then played for at least a hundred hours. It was a good demo.