Valve, who continues to expand the beta for CS:GO before a release this summer, has been vocal about its cooperation with the eSports community. But Tomi “lurppis” Kovanen believes that message hasn't been backed up by game design that's conducive to a competitive game. In a thread on the official forums, Kovanen calls CS:GO “terrible” and “not by any means fun.” He adds: “That's what every top player thinks as far as I can tell.”
These aren't the complaints of a forum wildman, they're from someone who formerly led Evil Geniuses' CS team, and who's earned $340,000 in (team) prize money playing CS since 2005. Why does Kovanen feel this way? I spoke with him to get more perspective on what he describes as a “handicapped” game.
In our interview, Kovanen, a CS 1.6 player, pointed to map changes, bad visibility, player movement, and recoil as aspects of design that he believes undermine CS:GO's chances at being a good competitive game.
“I played CS:GO for three hours a night, four nights in a row for the CES Plantronics thing. And on day four I still couldn't tell who was a CT or a T. So I just shot everyone at first to find out if they're a teammate or an enemy,” Kovanen says of CS:GO's “desaturated” lighting. “It feels almost black and white. It's really hard to see player models from textures or random objects in the map.”
See some of the differences between 1.6, CS:S, and CS:GO in the video above.
Changes to map geometry and layout are another sour point for Kovanen. “De_train is the worst with two towers, the bomb train in the middle of outside, oversized trains, ladders on the sides of trains, most of trains removed in the inner site, et cetera. De_nuke has a lot of its best parts removed without backstairs to lower and back bombsite and short hall in lower. It all feels like they just really want to handicap the game by making it easier.” From Valve's perspective, these map changes are probably in place to shake up tactics that've held up for more than a decade and accommodate new items and new game balance. Kovanen later added: “The game even has casual and competitive modes, I don't understand why they cant make them vastly different if necessary, sort of like a built-in ProMod .”
Kovanen is also unhappy about weapon recoil. “Right now it feels like the recoil is just too strong,” he says. “It's really hard to control (if even possible) and it feels like you could never spray at a spot, turn 90 degrees and still be accurate at another guy. You're basically stuck one-bulleting people or going for mindless sprays which might result in two people emptying their clips at one another with both people surviving. The bullet tracers are also really annoying and I don't understand why they're even in the game, It seems like another effect to make it more console-like; it's just something more that will get in the way of seeing things clearly.”
Other figures in CS' competitive community have been outspoken about CS:GO's current weapon feedback. Former pro and now-caster Jimmy Whisenhunt believes that screen movement is the issue, not recoil.
I asked Kovanen what aspect of CS:GO he'd like to see changed most. “Player movement. Not only does that play a giant role in the game being fun, it adds a lot of skill to it as well. One of the things that makes CS:GO so frustrating to play is that the movement feels sluggish and slow and you don't feel in perfect control of your character."
But Kovanen, who played on Team Europe in Valve's first big CS:GO showmatch late last year, says all this criticism stems from wanting the game to succeed. “I believe in eSports. And if there are a lot of people who enjoy the game like I have enjoyed CS 1.6 over the years, good for them. I'm sure there were people who disliked 1.6, yet it has played a big part in how the last seven years of my life, so I'd hope other people get to experience something similar in their lives. I hope it will be successful, but with the way the game currently is and how I believe it will end up without listening to us, I don't think it can be successful. I wouldn't be surprised if it got picked up for one or two years at most, and then FPS games got dropped out [from tournaments] as a whole because of lack of CS:GO popularity. The ironic thing is all the pros would wanna help to try to make it a decent game because they all know there would be more money, more tournaments, and so on if it was a good game and everyone switched.”
Valve continues to make changes to CS:GO leading up to the game's summer release . Will you watch CS:GO competitive play? How well do you think the game will do as an eSport?