Just one day after announcing planned changes to its branded content guidelines which established tight limits on how streamers would be allowed to run ads on their channels, Twitch is dropping the whole thing, saying the updated guidelines "are bad for you and bad for Twitch."
Of course, it all started over money. "We recognize that streamers want to collaborate with brands, but as outlined in the Terms of Service we maintain the exclusive right to sell, serve, and display advertisements on the Twitch Services," Twitch said yesterday. "This means that you may not insert, embed, or 'burn in' prerecorded advertising units into your livestream."
Those planned changes did not go over well, with anyone. High-profile streamers demanded that the new guidelines be changed or dropped; at least one streaming network threatened to leave the platform entirely if the new rules were allowed to stand.
It was enough that, several hours later, Twitch acknowledged that it had "missed the mark with the policy language" and promised to update "the language" to make the situation clearer. But this too was met with criticism, as many streamers pointed out that the problem wasn't that the policy was unclear, but that it was bad.
Twitch apparently got the message: Restrictions on content, like alcohol, gambling, and adult content, remain, but the entire "prohibited formats" section has now been removed.
"Yesterday, we released new Branded Content Guidelines that impacted your ability to work with sponsors to increase your income from streaming," Twitch said. "These guidelines are bad for you and bad for Twitch, and we are removing them immediately.
"Sponsorships are critical to streamers' growth and ability to earn income. We will not prevent your ability to enter into direct relationships with sponsors – you will continue to own and control your sponsorship business. We want to work with our community to create the best experience on Twitch, and to do that we need to be clear about what we're doing and why we're doing it. We appreciate your feedback and help in making this change."
It's a good move—the only move, really, given the intensity of the blowback—and streamers are largely happy with the outcome. What they're not happy about, however, is what's widely seen as an ongoing series of missteps and mismanagement, a negative perception that's exacerbated by Twitch's ongoing refusal to provide its streamers with a better revenue cut—a sentiment succinctly made by, among others, the popular streamer Gothalion, who called on Twitter to "walk that one back too."
70/30Walk that one back too. It’s bad for us and bad for you.June 7, 2023
Some streamers have also noticed that Twitch's terms of service now carry limitations on allowed types of advertising that are very similar to what was prohibited yesterday. The section on "advertisements," for instance, states:
"Twitch has the exclusive right to monetize the Twitch Services, including without limitation, the exclusive right to sell, serve, and display advertisements on the Twitch Services. This means you may not, nor may you allow a third party to, insert or embed prerecorded advertising units into your live stream, including without limitation video advertisements (whether pre-, mid-, or post-roll); display or 'banner' advertisements; and audio advertisements."
That sounds not too far off of what was announced yesterday and then walked back today, and some streamers are accusing Twitch of simply moving the advertising restrictions to a less visible location. I've reached out to Twitch for comment and will update if I receive a reply.