3DMark wars: Nvidia and AMD go head-to-head on our test rig. Who wins?

Dave James

Page 1 of 10

The new version of Futuremark's 3DMark has just been released, offering us all ways to benchmark our graphics cards and PCs by using Matrix-esque squid robots. And who wouldn't want to be able to do that?

I've grabbed the current top two single-GPU graphics cards from both AMD and Nvidia and have put them head-to-head in a battle royale to see who Futuremark's squid-bot believes is the quickest graphics card out there.

And the results aren't massively surprising.

The HD 7970 comes back with a score of 3,406 and the GTX 680 hits 3,013 on the Extreme settings of the 3DMark benchmark. On the standard settings the gap between the two top GPUs increases with the AMD card hitting 6,911 and the Nvidia card just 6,049.

I was speaking with Nvidia about this yesterday, and while they are more than happy to keep ensuring their drivers work perfectly with 3DMark to give Nvidia cards the best possible results, they still see it as less important than real-world game benchmarks.

That's perhaps not surprising given that AMD's HD 7970 gives the GTX 680 a good spanking in the overall results.

The Fire Strike test combines the physics and particle effects to make an intensive benchmark

But it's something I agree with too.

I haven't used the last few generations of the 3DMark benchmark suite for the simple reason that a 3DMark score is less relevant to most of us than a straight FPS score in a game that we're actually playing.

Given that a 3DMark score is also impacted by the CPU that is in the system, more than most game engines, it's not a straight test of graphics capability.

Realistically though you want as many benchmarks as possible to give you a rounded idea of just how well, or how badly, a given GPU is performing.

What's interesting about this version of 3DMark though is the amount of information it gives you afterwards and that makes better viewing for Nvidia than it does AMD.

The results graph is intriguing in that it shows a much larger, spikier variation in frame rate on the HD 7970 than it does on the GTX 680.

The Nvidia card is far smoother throughout the benchmark, and indicates that a GTX 680 will offer a more stable gaming experience even if it doesn't necessarily give the biggest average frame per second score at the end.

Around the web

by CPMStar (Sponsored) Free to play

Comments

highlights